Vigil to protest execution by Ohio, on March 10th 2011

From: Facebook 

Restore Justice will hold a vigil to protest the scheduled execution by Ohio of Jonnie Baston.

He is scheduled to be executed on Thurs. morning Mar. 10th. The vigil will be held at the Athens County Courthouse on Wed. Mar 9th from 6 to 7 pm.

We have much compassion and sympathy for the family and loved ones of the victim, Chong Mah. We feel that there is no reason for the state to execute Jonnie Baston.

We feel that all executions are murder and should be stopped immediately. For more information on this case go to

http://gamso-forthedefense.blogspot.com/2011/02/why-exactly-should-we-kill-johnnie.html
 
http://www.correctionsone.com/capital-punishment/articles/3295591-Ohio-killer-facing-new-execution-drug-wants-mercy/

The Governor of Ohio is not God’s agent on earth. He is our agent.

From: Gamso – For the Defense Blog

Friday, March 4, 2011

Tears Come Early

They won’t be killing him for another few days, not until Thursday next week.
I’m not sure why this one is hitting me so hard.  They’re all tough, of course.  Especially the ones I worked on.  But this is worst than most.
Maybe it’s because it’s so clearly wrong.
So a bit more background, maybe.
 
Johnnie Baston was sentenced to die by a three-judge panel that exhibited bias and prejudice against him at sentencing.  That’s basic error.  So basic that it should get an automatic new sentencing.  But the court of appeals, while acknowledging (though not in so many words) that the panel was biased, said that it’s mandated independent reweighing of the sentencing issues would cure the problem.
 
That’s wrong.  Fundamentally, legally wrong.
 
Then we went to the Supreme Court.  They said (again not in so many words) that they were legally obligated to agree that the three-judge panel was biased and prejudiced.  But because the panel wasn’t, it didn’t matter.
 
Are you deeply enough in fantasy yet?
 
Baston said from the time he was arrested that he didn’t shoot Chong Mah.  Some guy named “Ray” did the killing, Baston says.  It’s possible that one of the witnesses, a passer-by outside the wig shop, might have seen this Ray.  But the panel misrepresented his testimony so that it seemed the witness saw Baston, which the witness was clear he did not.  There’s other evidence that might be exculpatory.  Or maybe not.  But it doesn’t matter much now.
 
The victim’s family doesn’t want Baston killed.  I made a couple of efforts (here and here) last month to explain why their feelings should, at this stage, control.  I don’t know that I did a very good job of it, so let me try it much more simply now.
 
Clemency (which is what we’re talking about) isn’t about the law.  The law controls the procedures to be followed – the Parole Board must make a recommendation to the governor, after which the governor can do whatever he wants – but the law says nothing about how the decision to grant or deny clemency should be made.  That’s because clemency is a vestige of the divine right of kings.  The king, you see, was God’s agent in these matters, granting mercy whenever he wished.  Not because the recipient deserved it but because mercy is a gift to be bestowed at will.
 
The Governor of Ohio is not God’s agent on earth.  He is our agent.  So executive clemency isn’t about what God would do but what we would.   Here and now, as in medieval England, clemency isn’t (or at least shouldn’t be) about the recipient of the gift.  It’s about the giver.  About us.
We have been asked to spare him as a gesture to the family of the victim.  Surely we can do that.  Because we can be merciful even to those who themselves denied mercy.
Because we are better than that.
 
Or maybe not.
 
This afternoon, without comment, Governor Kasich said we’re not.  He denied clemency to Johnnie Baston.
 
Next Thursday, agents of the State of Ohio will kill him.
 
Not because he deserves to die.
 
But because we aren’t decent enough to let him live.
 
Baston, according to the prosecutor, the three-judge panel, the appellate courts, and the Parole Board, chose to murder Chong Mah.  He didn’t have to.  He chose to.
 
The panel, the appellate courts, the Parole Board, and now the Governor all chose to murder Johnnie Baston.  They didn’t have to.  They chose to.  On our behalf.
 
Only Baston (if it was he who killed Chong Mah) and the Governor made the decisions alone.  
Only they have nobody to whom the buck can be passed.
 
Baston still says he didn’t kill anyone.
 
We know for sure that Kasich is a killer.  
 

Governor rejects clemency request

Execution Thursday

Saturday, March 5, 2011  02:53 AM

THE COLUMBUS DISPATCH

Johnnie Baston was convicted of killing a Toledo shopkeeper, whose family opposes the death penalty.

Johnnie Baston was convicted of killing a Toledo shopkeeper, whose family opposes the death penalty.
 

Johnnie Baston didn’t expect to receive mercy from Gov. John Kasich. He got what he expected.

Kasich yesterday rejected Baston’s clemency request, virtually assuring that the convicted killer from Toledo will be executed as scheduled on Thursday. Baston has exhausted all legal appeals.

Urgent Action: Imminent Execution/Death Penalty USA (Ohio): Johnnie Baston

From Amnesty International:

Johnnie Baston, a 36-year-old African American man, is scheduled to be executed in Ohio on 10 March. He was sentenced to death in 1995 for a murder committed during a robbery in 1994.

Chong Hoon Mah, a South Korean immigrant to the USA, was shot and killed on 21 March 1994 during a robbery of one of the retail shops that he owned in Toledo, Ohio. Johnnie Baston was arrested after police received information that he was involved in the crime. He told police that he had participated in the robbery with an accomplice named “Ray”, a high-ranking gang member, who was the gunman. However, police were never able to identify or locate this person, and came to believe that Johnnie Baston acted alone. He was charged, pleaded not guilty, and chose to be tried before a three-judge panel rather than a jury. The judges sentenced him to death on 27 February 1995, finding only one mitigating factor – his young age – and ruling that this was outweighed by the nature of the crime.

Johnnie Baston has been on death row for 16 years, most of his adult life. At the time of the crime, he was just past his 20th birthday. He had been abandoned by his biological mother soon after he was born, and has never seen her since, his only communication with her being a letter from her after he was sent to death row. As a young boy, he was adopted by his aunt after she saw his bruising and malnourishment, evidence of a pattern of physical abuse and neglect in his first years at the hands of his father. At the clemency hearing before the Ohio Adult Parole Authority on 3 February 2011, his adoptive mother recalled that his parental abandonment had led to serious behavioural problems in his teenage years, culminating in her throwing him out of the home about a week before the crime.

Also at the clemency hearing was one of the prosecutors from the original trial. She said that Chong Mah’s son had asked her to appear to reiterate the victim’s family’s opposition to the execution of Johnnie Baston because of their respect for human life.

Last year she and another prosecutor signed sworn statements that the Mah family had been opposed to the death penalty at the time of the trial as well. Last month, Chong Mah’s son also signed a statement that “my family and I are opposed to Mr Baston being executed”.

A senior Justice on the Ohio Supreme Court has called for abolition of the state’s death penalty, describing it as a “death lottery” (see overleaf). By way of illustration, Johnnie Baston’s clemency petition points to the case of another defendant who was tried in the same county (Lucas County) for a comparable crime in 1994 (shooting of a store manager at close range during a robbery) and was sentenced to life imprisonment. The petition also pointed to the disproportionate number of death sentences passed against black defendants in Lucas County. Of the 21 death sentences passed there since 1981, in 16 cases the defendant was black, and in four cases white.

The parole board voted 9-0 against recommending clemency. Their recommendation is not binding on the Governor.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION
Amnesty International opposes the death penalty in all cases, unconditionally. To end the death penalty is to abandon a degrading, destructive, diversionary and divisive public policy that is not consistent with widely held values. It not only runs the risk of irrevocable error, it is also costly, in social and psychological terms as well as to the public purse. It has not been proved to have a unique deterrent effect. It tends to be applied in a discriminatory way, on grounds of race and class. It diverts resources that could be better used to work against violent crime and assist those affected by it. The death penalty extends the suffering of the victim’s family to that of the condemned prisoner.

Public and political support for the death penalty has weakened in recent years, and the rate of death sentencing has declined.

One possible factor contributing to this decline is the adoption across the US states of life without the possibility of parole. Ohio adopted this as a sentencing option in 1996, a year after Johnnie Baston’s trial. In the decade from 1990 to 1999, 127 death sentences were passed in Ohio, at an average of nearly 13 per year. In the following decade, the 43 death sentences were passed in the state, at an average of just over four per year.

In 2008, then Senior US Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens revealed that he had decided, after more than three decades on the country’s highest court, that the death penalty was a cruel waste of time. “I have relied on my own experience”, he wrote, “in reaching the conclusion that the imposition of the death penalty represents the pointless and needless extinction of life with only marginal contributions to any discernible social or public purposes”.

In Ohio, Senior Justice Paul Pfeifer of the state Supreme Court, who when he was a state legislator was a co-author of Ohio’s death penalty statute enacted in 1981, wrote inJanuary 2011: “I helped craft the law, and I have helped enforce it. From my rather unique perspective, I have come to the conclusion that we are not well served by our ongoing attachment to capital punishment… I ask: do we want our state government – and thus, by extension, all of us – to be in the business of taking lives in what amounts to a death lottery? I can’t imagine that’s something about which most of us feel comfortable. And, thus, I believe the time has come to abolish the death penalty in Ohio”. Also in January, a former Director of the Ohio Department of Corrections, who witnessed 33 executions between 2001 and 2010, urged Ohio officials to consider abolition of the death penalty.

There have been 1,242 executions in the USA since judicial killing resumed there in 1977, including eight so far this year. Ohio has executed 42 people since resuming executions in 1999. Thirty-two of them were put to death under a three-drug lethal injection process (sodium thiopental, pancuronium bromide, and potassium chloride) used in most US death penalty states to anesthetize, paralyze and kill the prisoner.

In November 2009 the Ohio authorities responded to ongoing legal challenges to the three-drug procedure – and to events two months earlier when the state’s lethal injection team attempted and failed over the course of two hours to execute death row prisoner Romell Broom – by changing to a one-drug protocol whereby the condemned inmate would be injected with five grams of sodium thiopental, essentially an overdose of this anaesthetic. Having executed 10 prisoners in this way between December 2009 and February 2011, but now faced with the nationwide sodium thiopental shortage after the only US supplier, Hospira, ceased production of this drug, Ohio has decided to switch to another barbiturate, pentobarbital. The execution of Johnnie Baston is due to become the first carried out in Ohio with this drug. From late 2010, Oklahoma turned to this drug as the substitute for sodium thiopental in its three-drug execution method.

In January, the Ohio authorities were contacted by the Denmark-based pharmaceutical company Lundbeck Inc. The letter states:

“In the wake of the decision of Hospira to cease production of sodium thiopental, which is used in the execution of prisoners, Lundbeck has become aware that the State of Ohio has now decided to use Lundbeck’s product Nembutal® (pentobarbital sodium injection USP) for this purpose. Lundbeck is adamantly opposed to the use of Nembutal, or any other product for that matter, for the purpose of capital punishment… [W]e urge you to discontinue the use of Nembutal in the execution of prisoners in your state because it contradicts everything we are in business to do – provide therapies that improve people’s lives.”

RECOMMENDED ACTION: Please send appeals to arrive as quickly as possible:

– Acknowledging the seriousness of the crime for which Johnnie Baston was sentenced to death;
– Calling on the governor to commute the death sentence and to work to lead Ohio away from the death penalty.

APPEALS TO:
Governor of Ohio
Governor John Kasich
Riffe Center, 30th Floor, 77 South High Street
Columbus, Oh 43215-6117,
USA
Fax: 1 614 466 9354
Email: http://governor.ohio.gov/ShareYourIdeas.aspx

Salutation: Dear Governor

PLEASE SEND APPEALS IMMEDIATELY.

Check with the AIUSA Urgent Action office if sending appeals after 10 March 2011

Victim’s Family Asks Ohio Board to Spare Inmate’s Life

From Death Penalty Information Center

The family of a man who was killed in Ohio recently petitioned the parole board to commute the death sentence of the defendant in the murder. Peter Mah, son of Chong Hoon Mah, who was killed by Johnnie Baston (pictured) during a robbery in 1994, told the Ohio Parole Board, “I was opposed to Mr. Baston receiving a death sentence at the time of his trial… [and] my family and I are opposed to Mr. Baston being executed.” During the trial, the family had filed affidavits saying that they preferred to see Baston spend his entire life in prison, but that sentencing option was not available at the time.

The Board makes a recommendation regarding clemency to the governor, who makes the final decision.  Baston’s attorneys have compared his case to that of Jeffrey Hill of Ohio, whose death sentence was commuted to life without parole by former Governor Ted Strickland. In Hill’s case, the parole board cited the wishes of the victim’s family opposing execution. Baston’s attorneys have also presented evidence that he was abused as a child by his birth family.

Baston is scheduled for execution on March 10.  If the execution goes forward, it will be by a method never used before in this country– a single dose of pentobarbital. UPDATE: The parole board unanimously rejected Baston’s petition for a recommendation of clemency.  (Feb. 11, 2011).

(J. Provance, “Killer to ask Ohio governor to spare his life, family of ’94 Toledo victim is against March execution,” Toledo Blade, February 2, 2011).  See Life Without Parole and Victims.

US inmate executed after temporary halt

Herald Sun (Australia)

ALABAMA executed a convicted murderer late Thursday local time after the US Supreme Court denied a stay of execution for the man accused of killing his wife as she held their young child in her arms.

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas had issued a temporary stay in order to give the court more time to review the case’s legal arguments shortly before Leroy White was scheduled to die at 6pm (10:00 AEDT).

But the high court later denied the request for a stay and White, 51, was put to death by lethal injection at Holman Correctional Facility in Atmore.

He had spent 22 years on death row.

Alabama Governor Bob Riley and the Alabama Supreme Court had earlier denied White’s bid for clemency.

White was 29 years old in October 1988, when he murdered his wife with two gunshots because she wanted a separation.

He also shot and wounded his sister-in-law.

His lawyers said he did not have adequate representation and should have had the opportunity to plead guilty to get life without parole, in order to avoid the death penalty.

“Mr White’s execution marks another step back from the commitment to heightened scrutiny and fair review that states and courts promised when the death penalty was reintroduced 35 years ago,” White’s lawyer Bryan Stevenson said in a statement.

“Today’s execution further demonstrates how capital punishment in this country has become arbitrary, unreliable and a sentence carried out mostly against those too poor, disabled and vulnerable to avoid lethal vengeance.”

The family of the victim opposed the execution, according to Stevenson.

White’s daughter, Latonya White, was just 17 months old when her mother was gunned down while holding her in her arms.

“For a long time I was very angry with my father for taking my mother away from me,” she wrote to the court.

“I now have a very close relationship with my father. I am deeply opposed to my father’s execution. Executing my father will do nothing to bring my mother back.”

Two executions have been carried out in the US since the start of 2011, after 45 last year and 52 in 2009.

In Alabama alone, 203 prisoners are on death row.

U.S. Supreme Court halts execution of Leroy White for further review

Published: Thursday, January 13, 2011
Al com

ATMORE, AL — The U.S. Supreme Court halted the execution of Leroy White this evening just moments before he was scheduled to die by lethal injection.

The court issued a temporary stay, under order by Justice Clarence Thomas, until it could finish reviewing the details of the appeal, said Brian Corbett, spokesman for the Alabama Department of Corrections.

White, 52, was convicted of murder in the Oct. 17, 1988, shotgun slaying of his estranged wife, Ruby White, at her northwest Huntsville home.

White will remain in a holding cell adjacent to the execution room at Holman Prison in Atmore until the Supreme Court gives further instruction, Corbett said.

White would be the fourth person from Madison County – and first since 1998 – executed since the state took over executions from the counties in 1927.

White’s request for clemency was denied this afternoon by Gov. Bob Riley.

White’s attorneys have argued that White did not receive good advice from his trial attorney who advised him not to take a plea deal that would have meant a life sentence without parole.

Attorney Bryan Stevenson, executive director of the Montgomery-based Equal Justice Initiative, said the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to take up a similar case, related to advice regarding plea deals, and its outcome should have a bearing on White’s case.

Stevenson has also argued that the victim’s family has asked that White not be executed and the jury in his case recommended a life sentence.

White has had several appeals rejected including one by the Alabama Supreme Court earlier today.